Posted by JohnL on June 12, 1999, at 2:21:21
In reply to Help, please, Doctors. Effexor and ?? question, posted by Racer on June 10, 1999, at 21:55:03
> Hi, I'm taking Effexor XR, now at 225mg/day. It's relieving the anxiety that usually goes along with depression for me, but interfering with my ability to sleep and (most importantly) not fixing the depression.
>
> My depression is worse in some ways now than without the medication. For one thing, I'm equally despondant, but without the lack of motivation which has proven helpful for me when I've been suicidal in the past. This is the first anti-depressant which has been relatively side effect free for me, but it's just not helping the depression.
>
> My own doctor will not listen to me. When I called to tell her that I'd spent four days straight crying and wanting to kill myself, she said that "meds won't help you. You have too many problems you'll have to work out before the meds will make you feel better." NOT therapeutic, by the way, if you're thinking of telling your own patients that. Anyway, one of the things that she said was that I should stay on the Effexor if it's doing anything at all, because she considers it successful if there is any relief in symptoms whatsoever. I'm really frightened right now, because I don't want to be dead, just to get some relief.
>
> So, here's my question: since Effexor is effective against the anxiety, and pretty easy on the side effects, is there anything that can be combined with it that might help with the depression? My doctor says that anti-depressants are never ever used in combination. That it must be one drug only, no matter what. This is different from most of what I've been reading, which says that combinations of drugs often work better than single drugs. Any information about any of this would be greatly appreciated.
>
> My greatest concerns are weight gain and sleepiness/grogginess, and lowered blood pressure. My blood pressure averages 90/60, so it can't go much lower. The other drugs I've tried have packed the pounds on me, 50 to 70 pounds. That is just not acceptable. The grogginess is self explanatory.
>
> I've tried Paxil (good for the depression, packed on 50 pounds or so, and made me anorgasmic and groggy), sinquan (for pain - lowered bp), nortriptyline (weight gain, somewhat effective on depression) and serzone (thoroughly awful). Any suggestions?
>
> Thanks for your time and advice.Racer, here a day later and I see there is no doctor response yet. Sorry. You know, for the whole day I couldn't stop thinking about that ridiculous doc of yours. That really struck a nerve with me. What kind of responsible practitioner of medicine seemingly ignores talk of suicide? Hey, in another post you mentioned driving 5 hours to another doc. Good idea. Don't think you're alone. My psychiatrist likes the idea of moclobomide, considering my long list of failures and/or side effect sensitivities, and approved me to drive to Canada to get some...5 hours for me. As my doc said, "Not everyone has a choice, you do. It's not like you're going to Africa. It's an afternoon drive." Go for it. I'll think about you over the hum of the tires, and I'll bet ya we aren't the only ones. Also, really study the posts here on Parnate (MAOI). Give it more of a consideration. Take care, best wishes, JohnL.
poster:JohnL
thread:7271
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/19990601/msgs/7302.html