Posted by DiscoPuppy on May 31, 2002, at 17:14:05
In reply to Ativan vs Tranxene vs Xanax vs Klonopin???, posted by 3 Beer Effect on May 30, 2002, at 14:03:38
Ok I just came up with a drawback for Ativan. I've tolerated Ativan to the point where I can't up my dosage anymore. Never had that problem with Xanax or Klon.
Needless to say, my bottle of Ativans are totally wasted.
> I've been taking Klonopin 1 mg 3x per day for daytime social anxiety for a long time now, but I am thinking of switching to a different benzo, since I'm somewhat dissapointed with Klonopin's anxiolytic effects. For anti-anxiety/anxiolytic Klonopin does not seem to work nearly as well 2-3 Beers does.
>
> Here are the three I was thinking of switching to-
>
> Ativan (lorazepam)- One book I have says this is "the most potent of the available benzodiazepines".
>
> Tranxene T (clorazepate dipotassium)- "Anxiolytic with actions, uses, & interactions qualitatively similar to those of Ativan but with fewer unwanted side effects, e.g. sedation." This has an onset of 1 hr but a duration of 24 hours, but it looks like it might metabolize to the same metabolite as Valium. Is Tranxene T (immediate release) a strong benzo like Ativan or Klonopin or a weak one like Valium?
>
> Xanax (alprazolam)-
> "associated with significantly less drowsiness. Has antidepressant as well as anxiolytic actions".
>
>
> Are any of these three (Ativan, Tranxene, or Xanax) better than Klonopin for daytime anxiety/social phobia or closer to the 3 Beer Effect i've been searching for?
> (I take Ambien 10 mg for sleep, so their sleep-inducing properties aren't important to me).
>
> Alcohol easily seems to be the best anxiolytic ever created-i've never found anything even remotely close.
>
> 3 Beers.................
poster:DiscoPuppy
thread:108066
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/20020525/msgs/108248.html